,

Loneliness by design

Designers treat loneliness like any other mechanic: empty space, silence, withheld contact and loss go in, and a feeling comes out.

The silhouette of a dark figure is in the midground of a foggy grey plain, with black script text reading 'Loneliness by design' above it

Somewhere in the third hour of a walk across Death Stranding’s mountains, you notice that nobody has spoken to you in a long time. There’s no music. There’s wind, the weight on your back and the next ridge.

That feeling shouldn’t be seen as a negative. Death Stranding, Firewatch and Spiritfarer look nothing alike, but each one makes you feel alone on purpose. They share a rule: none of them leave you with nothing. They give you a little company, then keep it just out of reach.

Most games treat travel as the dull bit between objectives, or some give you a vehicle in an attempt to make it more exciting. Death Stranding makes it the whole game, crossing a ruined America mostly on foot, and you feel every step. Slopes, rivers and loose rocks can knock you over, and your cargo shifts with your balance. Hours pass with no one else on screen, so the emptiness stops being scenery and becomes something you have to get used to.

Firewatch does it more gently, and in my opinion it’s story moves forward more. Its Wyoming forest is beautiful, but it’s also huge, quiet and a little unfriendly. You get a map and a compass, and sometimes you get lost. The forest doesn’t react to you. You are the only thing moving through the forest.

Sound helps too. Death Stranding leaves long stretches almost silent, so when a song finally starts at a key moment on the road, it gives some relief and brings you back. The silence makes the music feel like a gift.

In Firewatch, your only company is Delilah, a fellow lookout you talk to over a handheld radio. You choose what to say, and you can choose to say nothing, and she notices either way. Critic Brendan Keogh has called the game a “panopticon”: you are alone and almost never see anyone, yet the game keeps reminding you that someone might be watching. It ends the same way. You reach Delilah’s tower just after she has left, so you see where she was but never meet her.

Death Stranding is the oddest case. Other players’ ladders, bridges and shelters appear in your world, and you can leave them likes. That’s all. Someone you will never meet left a ladder exactly where you needed one, and all you can do is say thanks with a button. In a 2019 Game Informer interview, reported by Game Developer’s Alissa McAloon, Kojima said you can’t see other people’s faces, but “you can see the tracks and traces.” He added that the world is so bleak he wanted a system that felt more positive than negative, and compared it to a cinema, where hundreds of people watch the same film together.

Spiritfarer shows this so well. You play Stella, a ferrymaster who carries the dead to the afterlife, and the game asks you to look after the spirits on your boat. You build them homes, cook their favourite meals and hug them when they’re down. By the time a spirit is ready to leave, you’ve spent hours caring for them.

The game is built so that every spirit leaves. Kevin Wright, writing for Fandom, points out how far the design goes. Each goodbye gives you a Spirit Flower, which you spend on ship upgrades, so progress and loss are tied together. A faster ship, Wright notes, just brings the goodbyes sooner. He also says each spirit’s house stays on your boat after they go, overgrown with vines, unless you choose to remove it. The boat gets quieter with every farewell, and the game gets lonelier.

That’s different from a character dying in a cutscene. The loss isn’t something that happens to you. It’s something you do, with your own hands.

Wright describes Spiritfarer as turning emotional labour into gameplay, and all three games do a version of that. In a film, we watch a character feel alone. In a game, we walk the empty road, pick up the radio and cook a meal for someone we know is leaving. Nobody has to tell us to feel lonely. The game puts us where loneliness is the natural reaction.

The strangest part is that these games are lonely but rarely bleak. In a game, loneliness comes with a pause button and end credits, and most of them give something back: a ladder, a voice on the radio, a goodbye you got to say properly. Death Stranding’s story is about reconnecting, and it only works because the walk was lonely first.

Designers treat loneliness like any other mechanic: empty space, silence, withheld contact and loss go in, and a feeling comes out.

Image credit: Elin Tabitha on Unsplash

Author

Leave a Reply